At One Place

Which screw should I use in plastic?

Which screw should I use in plastic?
A thread-forming screw designed for plastic, or a heat-set threaded insert where the joint will be undone more than once.

Plastics fail at fixings in two ways: brittle materials such as polystyrene and acrylic crack from the hoop stress a thread creates, and ductile ones such as polypropylene creep, so a joint tightened today is loose in six months. Thread-forming screws for plastics are designed around both, with a wide thread angle to reduce hoop stress and a large flank area to spread load. The other rule is torque: plastic bosses strip at a fraction of the torque a metal thread takes, so a power driver on its highest clutch setting will destroy the boss before you feel anything. Anything intended to be opened more than a handful of times should have a metal insert rather than a thread cut in plastic.

The options, ranked

Ranked best-first for the stated job. The third column is why the others exist.
Option Good at Bad at
Thread-forming plastic screw A wide, shallow, single-lead thread displaces material rather than cutting it, so it does not crack the boss. Specific to plastics and not stocked everywhere.
Heat-set threaded insert Melts into a moulded boss and gives a metal thread that can be assembled repeatedly — the standard in 3D-printed parts. Needs a soldering iron and the right hole size.
Machine screw and captive nut Strongest and fully demountable. Needs access to both sides or a designed-in nut trap.
Standard woodscrew Works once in soft plastics. Its sharp, deep thread wedges brittle plastics apart, and every reassembly strips the hole further.

Technique that changes the outcome

  1. Use the boss and pilot dimensions the screw maker publishes; they are specific and they matter
  2. Set the driver clutch low and finish by hand
  3. For repeated assembly, install a heat-set insert with a temperature-controlled iron
  4. Support brittle plastic around the fixing so the hoop stress has somewhere to go

What goes wrong

  • Overtightening, which strips the boss in an instant
  • Woodscrews in brittle plastics
  • Reusing a stripped hole; move to an insert or a machine screw

Compiled practical guidance rather than a published standard. Product formulations vary by brand and market, so read the label — and where the work is structural, electrical or gas, the regulations that apply where you are govern rather than anything here.

Other screw questions

For Use
Wood A pilot hole matching the screw's core diameter in the lower piece and a clearance hole in the upper one — that is what makes a joint tight.
Decking Stainless steel — 304 inland, 316 near the coast — or a screw specifically rated for modern treated timber, which eats ordinary zinc plating.
Masonry A concrete screw into a precisely sized hole, or a plug and screw — and hollow block needs a different anchor entirely.
Plasterboard Coarse-thread bugle-head drywall screws into timber studs, fine-thread into metal studs — and never use them for anything structural.
MDF A straight-shank MDF screw with a parallel thread, always into a pilot hole — the edge splits without one.
Sheet metal A self-drilling (Tek) screw with a drill point matched to the material thickness, or a self-tapping screw into a correctly sized pilot hole.
Chipboard A twin-thread chipboard screw with an unthreaded shank under the head, so it pulls the joint together instead of bursting the board.
Roofing sheets A hex-head screw with a bonded EPDM washer, driven until the washer just spreads — no further.
Brass hardware Cut the thread with a steel screw of the same size first, wax the brass one, and use a driver that fits the slot exactly.

Common questions

Which screw should I use in plastic?
A thread-forming screw designed for plastic, or a heat-set threaded insert where the joint will be undone more than once.
What should I avoid?
Overtightening, which strips the boss in an instant Woodscrews in brittle plastics Reusing a stripped hole; move to an insert or a machine screw

Related pages

Sources

  1. Typical range compiled from manufacturer specifications — At One Place

How these figures are compiled and checked